高級中等學校課程綱要法律定位及行政救濟之研究

NCUIR > College of Hakka Studies > Graduate Institute of Law and Government > Electronic Thesis & Dissertation > Item 987654321/87182

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://ir.lib.ncu.edu.tw/handle/987654321/87182

Title:	高級中等學校課程綱要法律定位及行政救濟之研究
Authors:	黃奕彰;HUANG, YI CHANG
Contributors:	法律與政府研究所
Keywords:	高級中等學校課程綱要;課程綱要微調案;法規命令;行政救濟;senior secondary school curriculum guidelines;Curriculum Guidelines;finetuning of Curriculum Guidelines;regulations and orders;administrative relief
Date:	2021-09-27
Issue Date:	2021-12-07 15:52:14 (UTC+8)
Publisher:	國立中央大學
Abstract:	有關教科書審定中課程綱要之爭議，在我國總與政治扯上邊，早從國民政府來台前，課堂上教授的內容往往不脫離主政者所喜好，人民似僅能被動的接受主政者的喜好而無法有選擇的餘地，即便隨著時代演進，教育理論與教育方式均有或多或少的改變，但人民在教育體系被動的地位仍未曾改變。然而隨著台灣從威權走向民主，人民的屬性也不同以往，當人民有能力提出對於教育內容之意見，與政府的衝突是必然的，而台灣貴為法制社會，人民對於課綱訂定程序或內容若有合法性之質疑，理當尋求司法之救濟，原則上課綱為機關所為的行政行為，其救濟途徑應循行政訴訟，但現實是，本次103 年課綱微調事件卻因為司法實務將其定位為法規命令而無法獲得立即有效的救濟，也因此本論文試圖以釐清課綱的行政行為屬性為出發點，探討各學者間對於課綱不同行政屬性的看法以及救濟途徑，以供未來類似案件爭訟之參考。;In our coutry ,the disputes regarding on Curriculum Guidelines is always related to the politics. Before the National Government came to Taiwan, the content taught in the classroom is often not out of the preferences of the governor, and the people seem to be able to passively accept the preferences of the governor and have no choice. Even with the progress of the times, educational theories and methods have changed more or less, but the only thing that remains unchanged is that the people still on the passive position in the education system. However, as Taiwan has moved from Authoritarianism is moving towards democracy, and the attributes of the people are different from the past. When the people have the ability to put forward their opinions on the content of education, conflicts with the government are inevitable. Taiwan is a society under the rule of law. If the people have doubts about the legality of the Curriculum Guidelines or content ,it is reasonable to seek judicial relief. In principle, the Curriculum Guidelines is an administrative act performed by the administrative agency. The remedy should be through administrative litigation. However, the reality is that the Curriculum Guidelines fine-tuning incident in 2014 was positioned as a legal order due to judicial practice. It is impossible to obtain immediate and effective relief. Therefore, this thesis attempts to clarify the administrative behavior attributes of the Curriculum Guidelines as a starting point, and explores the views of various scholars on the different administrative attributes of the syllabus and the ways of relief, so as to provide reference for similar cases in the future.
Appears in Collections:	[Graduate Institute of Law and Government] Electronic Thesis & Dissertation

Files in This Item:

File	Description	Size	Format
index.html		0Kb	HTML	118	View/Open

社群 sharing

Loading...