基進女性主義母職︰重思芮曲與費爾史東

以作者查詢圖書館館藏

、以作者查詢臺灣博碩士

、以作者查詢全國書目

、勘誤回報

、線上人數：10

、訪客IP：3.145.42.94

姓名

張玉芬(Yu-Fen Chang) 查詢紙本館藏

畢業系所

英美語文學系

論文名稱

基進女性主義母職︰重思芮曲與費爾史東
(Radical Feminists on Motherhood: Adrienne Rich and Shulamith Firestone Reconsidered)

相關論文

★ 新科技、商品化及女性：烏蘇拉．胡斯論消費勞動	★ LGBT非政府組織的聯合國倡導
★ The Question of A Feminist Subject in Li Ang	★ Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s Critique of Feminine Domesticity: The Yellow Wallpaper and Herland
★ Perverse Penumbrae in Exile: Multiple Technologies of Sexual Policing and Discipline in Crystal Boys	★ 主體言說？--影集「慾望城市」的傅柯權力分析
★ 一個再現的問題:閱讀天堂電話不通中的知識份子和賤民	★ 從白先勇孽子到公視孽子
★ 三位亞美女作家的雙重書寫	★ 弱勢酷兒的文本政治：閱讀《羅莉塔》、《繁花聖母》、《天河撩亂》
★ Gay Rave Culture and HIV Prevention: A Subcultural Intervention in Public Policy	★ No Shame in the Game of Love: On Killing Husband and Osmanthus Alley
★ “Bad Habits”: Bisexual Practices in Taiwan as Tactics of Sexual Politics	★ 批判2003年至2009年台灣的反人口販運運動
★ 情感裂隙與酷兒（對抗）位置性：當代台灣男同志E藥文化中的性與親密關係	★ 張亦絢<<壞掉時候>>與<<最好的時光>>中的糾結情感

檔案

[Endnote RIS 格式]

[Bibtex 格式]

[相關文章]

[文章引用]

[完整記錄]

[館藏目錄]

[檢視]

[下載]

本電子論文使用權限為同意立即開放。
已達開放權限電子全文僅授權使用者為學術研究之目的，進行個人非營利性質之檢索、閱讀、列印。
請遵守中華民國著作權法之相關規定，切勿任意重製、散佈、改作、轉貼、播送，以免觸法。

摘要(中)

本論文的研究重點在於女性主義的母職論述。在台灣的女性主義文本中，本地女性主義者對母職的態度一直曖昧不清。大多是將母職視為社會或文化問題，而沒有探索和發掘其身體及心理的意義。然而，代理孕母的議題使得女性主義者也不得不面對母職的基進層面--身體與生殖。大多數台灣女性主義者相信代理孕母是父權壓迫女性的新形式，但另有其他人認為代理孕母將從基本上鬆動父權。
本人在此論文中重讀安竺．芮曲的<女人所生>及舒拉米思．費爾史東的<性的辯證>，做為基進思考母職的重要論述基本。芮曲認為母職在本質上是女性力量的來源，因而鼓勵擁抱母職。費爾史東則認為母職是天生的壓迫，故提議以人工生殖將男女從天生的生殖功能限制中解放出來。對於豐富和拓展本地女性主義的母職觀點，二者的論點皆非常值得重新思考。

摘要(英)

The focal issue in this thesis is feminist discourses on motherhood. In Taiwan feminist texts, local feminists’attitudes toward motherhood are ambiguous. They mainly treated motherhood as a social and cultural problem, without exploring and discovering the physical and psychological meanings. However, the issue of surrogate motherhood forces feminists to face the radical level of motherhood—body and reproduction. Most of the Taiwan feminists believe surrogate motherhood is a new way of women’s oppression of patriarchal motherhood. But some others argue surrogate motherhood will shake the patriarchy in a fundamental way.
To reconsider motherhood radically, I reread Adrienne Rich’s Of Woman Born and Shulamith Firestone’s The Dialectic of Sex. Rich has critically pondered her own experiences of motherhood radically both in terms of physiology and psychology. She believes that the motherhood could be powerful and enjoyable, but the patriarchal institution has made it suffering. Therefore she goes on exploring the stigmatized potentials of motherhood. On the contrary, Firestone thinks motherhood is repressive in itself. She argues reproduction is the original division of labor. Only the technology of artificial reproduction can liberate women from the root of women’s oppression. Although Rich’s and Firestone’s viewpoints are different and even opposite, both of them mean to empowering women and mothers. Their radical arguments are worth reconsidering to enrich and enlarge local feminist perspectives on motherhood.

關鍵字(中)

★ 基進女性主義
★ 家庭
★ 父權
★ 母職
★ 生殖
★ 人工生殖

關鍵字(英)

★ reporduction
★ artificial reproduction
★ radical feminism
★ family
★ patruarchy
★ motherhood

論文目次

Chapter 1. Introduction ...................................1
Chapter 2. Rich: Motherhood as the Source of Power .......14
I. The Institution of Motherhood .................15
II. The Physiology of Motherhood .................22
III. The Psychology of Motherhood ................28
Chapter 3. Firestone: Motherhood as the Root of Oppression.36
I. Freudianism in a Feminist-Materialist Sense ....38
II. History of the Family .........................41
III. Reproduction and Technology ..................46
Chapter 4. Conclusion .....................................50
Bibliography ...............................................59

參考文獻

Aries, Philippe. Centuries of Childhood: A History of Family Life. Trans. Robert Baldick. Paris: Librarie Plon, 1960. New York: Vintage, 1962.
Editorial Office. “Mothers--Holy an Merciful?”（母親聖潔又慈祥） Awakening（婦女新知） 5 May 1995: 2-3.
“Awakening’s Opinions.”（本社的意見） Editorial. Awakening（婦女新知） 10 Aug. 1983: 25-26.
Chen, Meihua.（陳美華） “Radical Thinking about Surrogate Motherhood.”（關於代理孕母的激進思考） Awakening（婦女新知） Mar. 1999. Online. Awakening Foundation. 10 July 2003. http://www.awakening.org.tw/pubdtl.asp?artno=A00000000027
Chen, Yingshan.（陳盈珊） “Women’s Groups Express Different Voices.”（婦女團體發表不同聲音） China Times（中國時報） 9 Mar. 1999. Online. 10 July 2003.
Chen, Zuaozi.（陳昭姿） God! Why Can’t You Give Me a Child?: Chen Zhaozi Challenges Her Barrenness Fate.（神啊!為什麼不給我一個孩子?-陳昭姿挑戰不孕命運） Taipei: Yuanshuei,（原水）2002.
Farson, Richard. Birthrights: A Bill of Rights fro Children. New York: Macmillan, 1974.
Firestone, Shulamith. The Dialectic of Sex: The Case for Feminist Revolution. Morrow, 1970. New York: Bantam, 1971.
Gu, Yanling.（顧燕翎） Preface. Feminist Theories and Branches.（女性主義理論與流派） Taipei: Fembook,（女書店）1996.
---. “The New and Old Career of Rent-a-Body: Surrogated Mother and Prostitute.”（出租身體的新舊行業） Awakening（婦女新知） Sep. 1997: 16.
---. Introduction. Feminist Scripture: The Eighteen-Century European Enlightenment, the Twentieth-Century Local Reflection.（女性主義經典：十八世紀歐洲啟蒙，二十世紀本土反思） Ed. Gu Yanling and Zheng Zhhuei. Taipei: Fembook, 1999.
---. “The Development of Taiwan Women’s Movement and Consciousness.”（台灣婦女運動與女性意識的發展） Address. Excerpted by Chang Xiaoyan.（暢曉燕） Awakening July 1987: 1-5.
Goodman, Erika. “American Literature Web Resources: Adrienne Rich.” 1999. Project CROW. Online. Millikin University. 30 June 2003. http://www.millikin.edu/ACI/CROW/chronology/richbio.html
Ho, Josephine Chuen-Juei.（何春蕤） “Feminism and Surrogate Mother.”（女性主義與代理孕母） Keynote speech. The Hearing of the Controversy over the Draft of Artificial Insemination Law. Legislative Yuan. 11 Mar. 1999.
---. “New Struggle of the Body: Reply to Gu Yanling’s ‘The New and Old Career of Rent-a-Body.’”（身體的新抗爭︰回應顧燕翎＜出租身體的新舊行業＞） China Times Forum（中國時報時論廣場）17 Sep. 1997. Online. 14 July 2003. http://sex.ncu.edu.tw/members/ho/J269.htm
Huang, Chuenjing.（黃春菁） “Artificial Insemination Law, Dispute Over Surrogate Mother.”（人工生殖法代母惹爭議） Taipei. Lihpao Daily（立報）23 May 2002.
Huang, Xioujin.（黃秀錦） “Legalization of Surrogate Mother: a Doctor’s Viewpoint.”（代理孕母合法化︰醫生說法） China Times（中國時報） 9 Mar. 1999. Online. 10 July 2003.
---. ““Legalization of Surrogate Mother: a Scholar’s Viewpoint.”（代理孕母合法化︰學者說法） China Times（中國時報） 9 Mar. 1999. Online. 10 July 2003.
Ke, Zh-en.（柯至恩） The New Experience of a Motherhood.（柯至恩談母職心體驗） Taipei: Sitak（希代）,2000.
Knapp, James F. “Biography of Adrienne Rich.” The Norton Poetry Workshop. CD-ROM. LITWEB: An Online Companion to the Norton Introduction to Literature. Online. 2001. W.W. Norton & Company. 1 July 2003. http://www.wwnorton.com/introlit/poetry_rich5.htm
Lan, Peijia.（藍佩嘉） “Motherhood: An Institution Annihilating Women.”（母職：消滅女人的制度） of “Subverting ‘Motherhood.’”（顛覆「母職」） Con-Temporary.（當代） 1 June 1991: 84-88.
Li, Jiayan.（李佳燕） “Legalization of Surrogate Motherhood: an Endless Debate.”（代理孕母合法化－無法休止的論辯） 15 Mar. 1999. Esouth Digital Bulletin.（南方電子報）Online. 14 July 2003. http://www.south.nsysu.edu.tw/sccid/today/99/03/990315.html
Li, Yuanzhen.（李元貞） “To Be a Modern Mother.”（做一個新時代的母親） Awakening（婦女新知） 1 May 1982: 4-5.
---. “Who Cares Mother’s Human Rights?”（誰來關心母親的人權） Awakening（婦女新知） 10 May 1983 a: 6-8.
---. “From Motherhood to Fatherhood.”（從母性到父性） Awakening（婦女新知） 10 Aug. 1983 b: 10-12.
---. “Review and Expectation of Women’s Movement.（婦女運動的回顧與展望） Awakening. Oct. 1986: 4-6.
---. Women Step Out.（婦女開步走） 2nd. ed. 1988. Taipei: Awakening Foundation,（婦女新知基金會）1990.
---. Women’s Time to Come.（女人的明天） Taipei: Jianxing,（健行）1991.
McElroy, Wendy. “Feminists against Women: the New Reproductive Technologies.” rev. from “Breeder Reactionaries: the ‘feminist’ war on reproductive technologies.” Reason Dec. 1994. On line. 14 July 2003. http://www.zetetics.com/mac/reason.htm
O’Leary, Dale. “Feminism.” 1994. EWTN Library. Online. EWTN. 1 July 2003. http://www.ewtn.com/library/ISSUES/FEMINISM.TXT
Parker, Alan, dir. The Road to Wellville.（台譯：窈窕男女） Screenplay by Alan Parker. Perf. Anthony Hopkins, Bridge Fonda, Mathew Boderick, John Cusack. Columbia. 1994.
Rich, Adrienne. Of Woman Born: Motherhood as Experience and Institution. Tenth anniversary ed. 1976. Introd. Adrienne Rich. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1986.
Su, Qianling.（蘇芊玲） No Longer a Model Mother.（不再模範的母親） Taipei: Fembook, 1996.
---. My Practice of Motherhood.（我的母職實踐） Taipei: Fembook, 1998.
Tong, Rosemarie Putnam. Feminist Thoughts: A More Comprehensive Introduction. 2nd ed. Oxford: Westview, 1998.
Xu, Xiaoci.（徐孝慈） “Opposite Opinions in the Hearing of Surrogate Mother.”（代理孕母公聽會﹐正反意見兩極） China Times（中國時報） 12 Mar. 1999. Online. 10 July 2003.
Wang, Rueixiang.（王瑞香） “Radical Feminism: The Radical Prospect for Women’s Liberation.”（基進女性主義：女性解放的根本契機） Feminist Theories and Branches: The Most Complete Locally-Written Feminist Reader（女性主義理論與流派：本土撰寫最完整女性主義入門讀本） Ed. Gu Yian-ling.（顧燕翎） Rev. ed. 1996. Taipei: Fembook, 2000.
“Women and Marxism.” MIA: Marxist Internet Archive. Online. 1 July 2003. http://www.marxists.org/subject/women/
Zhang, Liwen.（張王黎文） “Surrogate Mother? Women Have Opposite Opinions.”（代理孕母？婦女看法兩極） China Times（中國時報） 7 Mar. 1999. Online. 10 July 2003.
Zheng, Zhhuei.（鄭至慧） “From No Unit to Collective Voicing.”（從沒有單位到集體發聲） The Whirling 80s: Recording a Collective Voicing Era.（狂飆八○：記錄一個集體發聲的年代） Ed. Yang Ze（楊澤） Taipei: China Times（時報文化）, 1999.

指導教授

丁乃非(Nai-Fei Ding)

審核日期

2003-7-20

推文