以作者查詢圖書館館藏

、以作者查詢臺灣博碩士

、以作者查詢全國書目

、勘誤回報

、線上人數：8

、訪客IP：3.135.249.223

姓名	李素貞(Su-Chen Lee)  查詢紙本館藏	畢業系所	哲學研究所
論文名稱	醫助自殺與死亡尊嚴的倫理探討 (The Ethics of Physician-Assisted Suicide and Dignity of Death)
相關論文	★ 諾丁關懷倫理學的道德理論研究 ★ 《莊子》命論之研究 ★ 宋代天台山家山外第二次論諍─以智者大師的原始思想決疑 ★ 判斷底邏輯形式與範疇－康德「範疇之形上推證」研究 ★ 梁漱溟文化哲學研究 ★ 許敬菴.周海門九諦九解義理研究 ★ 對諮詢同意原則之反思：哈伯馬斯溝通理論之應用 ★ 從女性主義論墮胎的道德爭議： 胎兒道德地位與女性身體自主權 ★ 論癌末病人知情權 ★ 從儒家觀點省思複製人的倫理問題 ★ 論基因倫理:基因治療及基因增強相關之倫理爭議 ★ 代理孕母與親子關係:一個倫理分析 ★ 無行為能力病人的醫療代理決策研究：以智能障礙者為例 ★ 高爾拔(Lawrence Kohlberg)的道德教育理論之道德哲學面向研究 ★ 自願安樂死的出路---從死亡權的角度分析 ★ 論癌末病人醫助自殺之道德性
檔案	[Endnote RIS 格式]    [Bibtex 格式]    [相關文章]   [文章引用]   [完整記錄]   [館藏目錄]   [檢視]  [下載] 本電子論文使用權限為同意立即開放。 已達開放權限電子全文僅授權使用者為學術研究之目的，進行個人非營利性質之檢索、閱讀、列印。 請遵守中華民國著作權法之相關規定，切勿任意重製、散佈、改作、轉貼、播送，以免觸法。
摘要(中)	目前在臨終照顧上，安寧照顧通常是優先的選擇，雖然如此，仍有少數人為了末期生命的品質，不想自然死，也不想經由臨終鎮靜昏昏沉沉的睡下去，而希望提早死亡，因此有醫師協助自殺的需求。對此需求，存在著立法的合法性與倫理上的爭議。本論文的研究目的主要探討醫助自殺各層面的倫理問題與合法化的可能性。論證醫助自殺是一種醫療行為，它可以成為安寧療護的一環，讓末期病人在臨終照護的選擇上多一種選項，以協助病人達到所期望的生活品質與死亡尊嚴。相較於安樂死，醫助自殺在臨終照護上應該是比較能夠被接受而合法化。在研究方法上，本文以倫理分析為主，並應用臨床研究，作為論證之參考。 在意涵方面，醫助自殺不同於一般的自殺。資料分析顯示需求者以末期癌症病人為主，而需求醫助自殺的原因最多為由身體症狀引發的難以忍受的痛苦，還有失去自主性、失去尊嚴等。醫護人員對病人需求醫助自殺的態度與經驗方面顯示，目前為止，大部分的醫護人員反對醫助自殺。本文首先對奎爾醫師所提出的醫助自殺的臨床準則，加以倫理分析，並提出修正與補充，作為未來醫助自殺合法化的標準模式。在末期病人臨終醫療處置方面，本文比較醫助自殺與自然死、自願停止進食與水分、臨終鎮靜與安樂死在倫理上之異同，提出醫助自殺做為臨終照護的一個選項的可能性。 本文進而從死亡權的探討，分析學者贊成與反對醫助自殺合法化的理由，個人認為應考量到對病人自律自主權利的尊重，承認病人在末期嚴重病痛之下有放棄繼續活著的權利。只是個別醫護人員卻沒有醫療的義務協助病人自殺。因此病人死亡權的落實，尤其是積極的死亡權部分，必須法律的保障，如此病人不只有道德的權利可以得到幫助，醫護人員也可按其價值選取而決定是否參與協助病人得到醫療的協助。由國家保障病人可依其意願達到死亡的尊嚴。 其次，本文最後從儒家的倫理觀點，論述醫助自殺在仁心、不忍人之心與經權原則之下，可以是人道上可被接受的出路。由於儒家思想重視家庭倫理，因此不只病人的自願性，家屬的參與也應受到高度的尊重。在宗教信仰上，台灣多元文化的信仰所形成的生命價值觀，死亡不一定是壞事。只是在醫病關係上，單有仁心仁術不足以協助病人自殺，必須要有良好而持久的醫病關係，病人的需求才不會被扭曲，因此在我國，家庭醫師制度的建立是很重要的。 本篇論文的貢獻包括：一、提出醫助自殺可能的臨床準則。本研究嘗試著以奎爾醫師所提的對醫助自殺的七項臨床準則為基準，對照尊嚴死法案，提出醫助自殺可能的法案。二、儒家思想於醫助自殺倫理議題的會通。儒家講求的是醫病家屬的心安，若是末期病人在良好而持久的醫病關係之下，能清楚的了解自己疾病的預後，加上親近家屬的支持，以醫助的方式提早死亡可以緩解病人的痛苦，那麼死亡是「仁」的體現，可以讓病人、家屬心安。其次，若醫助自殺合法化，醫護人員協助病人是「仁心」的表現，仁心的發用，才能讓醫護人員心安。三、在臨床研究方面，本人在台灣醫護的研究與觀察結果發現，在對醫助自殺的接受度方面，醫師與護理人員贊成醫助自殺合法化都不到半數 (醫師占30%，護理人員占39.3%)。但在經驗方面，醫師部分，病人或家屬曾經需求過醫助自殺者達10-14.3%，而護理人員亦達9.2-12.8%。顯然台灣目前醫護人員對協助自殺接受度不高，但少數末期病人卻有這部份的需求。對於未來的展望，本研究認為若病人對醫助自殺的需求要被認同，需要幾方面的配合，包括社會對醫助自殺的認同，醫護人員對醫助自殺的認同，良好的醫病關係和護病關係，還有讓醫助自殺或醫助死亡成為安寧療護的一環。
摘要(英)	Palliative care is the first choice of terminal care at the moment. However, there are patients who still want to die other than no natural death because of the poor life quality at terminal stage. Nor would they prefer terminal sedation, which put them to a drowsy sleep for a long time. These cases require ‘physician-assisted suicide (PAS)’, which is a legally and ethically debated issue. The aim of my dissertation is to investigate the ethical issue and the possibility of legalization of PAS especially in Taiwan and try to demonstrate that PAS is another type of medical practice, which provides a further choice of palliative care for terminal patients in order to achieve their expected quality of life and dignity. In contrast to euthanasia, PAS is morally more acceptable to be legalized. This dissertation is basically an ethical analysis of the issue with certain references to clinical studies. The meaning of PAS is quite different from ordinary suicide. The evidences showed that people who required PAS were mainly terminal cancer patients. They request PAS due mostly to unbearable physical pains, followed by loss of autonomy and dignity. Most medical practitioners, however, oppose to PAS. In this dissertation, I start from the ethical analysis of reasonable criteria of PAS proposed by Dr.T.E.Quill, and supplement them with some suggestions and modification, which would hopefully provide a standard model for the consideration of legalization of PAS. In terms of the medical care for terminal patients, I compare the differences between PAS and natural death, voluntarily stopping of nutrition and fluid, terminal sedation as well as euthanasia, and propose PAS as one possible choice for terminal care. The dissertation deliberates further on the right to death of the patient and the reasons for and against PAS in the literature. I support patients’ right and autonomy in particular their right to die at terminal stage. However, individual medical practitioner has no obligation to assist their patients to commit suicide. Laws should be established for protecting patient’s right to die. By legislation, not only the patients’ moral rights are protected, but medical practitioners could also have the choice to participate or not in PAS according to their personal values. Government has the duty to let patient’s wish for a death with dignity be honored. Furthermore, the dissertation elaborates the Confucian’s view on PAS ,my analysis is based on the basic of Confucian’s conception of the mind of ren or the unbearable mind of other’s suffering and the principle of ching-chuan to show why certain cases of PAS is permissible. Confucianism emphazise family relationship, therefore it is not only the patient’s voluntary decision should be respected, but also their family members’ participation are fully acknowledged. In terms of the pluralistic religious believes in Taiwan, death is not necessarily a bad thing. However, in case of PAS, doctor’s benevolent heart and medical skills may not be enough to carry out PAS for the patients, a long term well maintained doctor-patients relationship is essential. Therefore, in Taiwan, it would be most important to establish a good system of family doctors. The contributions of this dissertation include: (1) The proposal of possible clinical criteria of PAS. By comparing the criteria of Quill’s seven requirements with the Dignity Death Act, I propose a possible PAS for Taiwan. (2) The argumentation of PAS in Confucian terms shows that Confucianism tends to support PAS for terminal painful patients. For Confucianism, it is most important to let the medical practitioners, the patient and patient’s family feel peaceful. Death could be the regarded as the practice of ren if the terminal patient understands his/her own illness, and chooses PAS with family support. This should also be based on a long term well-established doctor-patient relationship, so that all parties feel peaceful for the decision. (3) According to my clinical study and observation on medical professionals in Taiwan, less than half of the physicians and nurses support the idea of legalizing PAS. (30% of physicians and 39.3% of nurses support PAS legalization). 10-14.3% of physicians and 9.2-12.8% of nurses had the experiences of being requested for PAS by patients or their family members. Obviously, although PAS is still not widely accepted by the medical practitioners, some terminal patients demand for this treatment. To carried out patient’ PAS, we need the support of the wider society as well as medical practitioners’ recognition of PAS as part of palliative care.
關鍵字(中)	★ 儒家 ★ 病人自主權 ★ 人格尊嚴 ★ 醫助自殺 ★ 死亡權	關鍵字(英)	★ physician-assisted suicide ★ the right of death ★ personal dignity ★ autonomy od patient ★ Confucianism
論文目次	第一章 導論 第一節 研究動機與背景 1 第二節 醫助自殺倫理爭議之回顧 5 第三節 醫助自殺所涵蓋之倫理問題與其重要性 15 第四節 研究方法、目的與章節架構 19 第二章 醫師協助自殺的意涵 第一節 醫助自殺之背景與意涵 21 一、 背景 二、 醫助自殺的意涵 三、 醫助自殺的名辭爭議 第二節 醫助自殺與自殺之異同 30 一、 自殺的意涵 二、 自殺分類 三、 自殺的倫理爭議 四、 醫助自殺與自殺之異同 第三節 醫助自殺的理由與限制 32 一、 需求醫助自殺的理由 二、 醫助自殺的限制 第四節 需求醫助自殺的病人 35 一、 需求者的特性 二、 影響病人需求醫助自殺的因素 第五節 醫護人員對醫助自殺的態度與經驗 39 一、 醫師的態度與經驗 二、 護理人員與其他醫事人員的態度與經驗 小結 第三章 醫助自殺臨床準則的倫理分析 第一節 奎爾與醫助自殺的臨床準則 47 第二節 臨床準則的倫理分析 49 一、 尊重自主原則 二、 不傷害原則 三、 行善原則 四、 公義原則 第三節 醫助自殺臨床準則的修正與補充 72 一、 奧勒岡尊嚴死法案之安全規範 二、 醫助自殺臨床準則的修正與補充 第四節 臨床準則的臨床應用 76 小結 第四章 醫助自殺與其他臨終醫療處置之異同 第一節 醫助自殺與自然死之異同 81 一、 自然死之意涵 二、 醫助自殺與自然死之異同 第二節 醫助自殺與自願停止進食和水分之異同 83 一、 自願停止進食和水分之意涵 二、 自願停止進食和水分之倫理爭議 三、 醫助自殺與自願停止進食和水分之異同 第三節 醫助自殺與臨終鎮靜之異同 87 一、 臨終鎮靜之意涵 二、 臨終鎮靜之倫理爭議 三、 醫助自殺與臨終鎮靜之異同 第四節 醫助自殺與安樂死之異同 90 一、 安樂死之意涵 二、 安樂死之倫理爭議 三、 醫助自殺與安樂死之異同 小結 第五章 死亡權的探討 第一節 人的權利 97 第二節 死亡法案的發展 102 一、 自然死法案 二、 尊嚴死法案 三、 安樂死與醫助自殺法案 第三節 死亡權的倫理爭議 108 一、 主張有死亡的權利者 二、 主張人沒有死亡的權利者 第四節 醫助自殺與死亡的尊嚴 116 一、 人性的尊嚴 二、 死亡的尊嚴 三、 醫助自殺與死亡尊嚴的相關性 小結 第六章 從儒家文化的觀點探討醫助自殺的倫理議題 第一節 儒家的倫理觀 125 一、 仁心 二、 不忍人之心 三、 經權原則 第二節 中西方生活文化的差異 128 一、 儒家之家庭倫理與個人抉擇 二、 多元文化信仰與基督文化 三、 醫病關係與家庭醫師 小結 第七章 結論 第一節 論文的貢獻 133 一、 醫助自殺可能的臨床準則 二、 儒家思想的匯通 三、 臨床研究的應用 第二節 醫助自殺的未來展望 135 一、 社會對醫助自殺的認同 二、 醫護人員對醫助自殺的認同 三、 良好的醫病關係和護病關係 四、 醫助自殺成為安寧療護的一環 五、 醫助自殺可能的法案 參考書目 139 附錄一 臨床研究—醫護人員對醫助自殺的態度與經驗 147 附錄二 美國奧勒岡尊嚴死法案 156
參考文獻	參考資料 一、 中文書目 大衛．凱斯勒(David Kessler)著，陳貞吟譯，2000，《臨終關懷》，台北：商流文化事業。 朱建民，葉保強，李瑞全著，2005，《應用倫理與現代社會》，台北：國立空中大學印行。 亞里斯多德(Aristotle)著，2001，苗力田譯著，《倫理學》，台北：知書房。 牟宗三著，1983，《中國哲學十九講》，台北：台灣學生書局。 李瑞全著，1990，《儒家生命倫理學》，台北：鵝湖出版社。 辛格(Peter A. Singer)編著，蔡甫昌編譯，2009，《臨床生命倫理學》，第二版，財團法人醫院評鑑暨醫療品質策進會出版。 佛蘭克(Frankl V.E,1967)著，趙可式，沈錦惠譯，《活出意義來：從集中營說到存在主義》，台北：光啟出版社。 波伊曼(Pojman)著，江麗美譯，1997，《生與死-現代道德困境的挑戰》，香港：桂冠。 波伊曼(Pojman)著，魏德驥譯，1997《解構死亡—死亡、自殺、安樂死與死刑的剖析》，台北：桂冠圖書。 紀欣著，2003，《生死一線間－安樂死與死刑制度之探討》，台北：商周出版社。 海倫‧聶爾寧(Helen Nearing)著，張燕譯，1993《美好人生的摯愛與告別》，台北：正中書局。 涂爾幹(Durkheim)著，黃丘隆譯，1990，《自殺論》，台北：結構群。 約翰‧彌爾(John Stuart Mill)著，郭志嵩譯，2004，《論自由》，台北：臉譜出版社。 鄂爾(Orr, Robert D.)等著，章福卿譯，1997，《認識生命倫理學》，台北：校園書房。 湯瑪斯．薩斯（Thomas Szasz）著，吳書榆譯，2001，《自殺的權利》，台北，商周出版。 恩格爾哈特（H.Tristram Engelhardt）著，范瑞平譯，2006，《生命倫理學基礎》，第二版，北京大學出版社，頁353。 康德(Kant,Immanuel)著，李明輝譯，1990，《道德底形上學之基礎》，台北：聯經出版。 傅偉勳著，1993，《生命的尊嚴與死亡的尊嚴》，台北：正中書局。 劉俊榮，2007，《人文視野中的醫學》，南京：江蘇人民出版社。 德沃金(Ronald Dworkin)著,司馬學文譯，2007，《人權與民主生活》，台北：韋伯文化。 謝啟武著，傅偉勳/韋政通主編，1997，《洛克》，台北：東大圖書。 FrederickCopleston原著，朱建民、李瑞全譯，1993，《西洋哲學史(五)—近代哲學》，台北：黎明文化事業。 二、 碩博士論文 李素貞，2003，《死亡的尊嚴與本真的向死存在—安樂死與海德格的死亡觀》，南華大學哲學研究所碩士論文。 張馨文，2006，《辛格論醫助自殺》，國立中央大學哲學研究所碩士論文。 三、 中文學刊 方慧芬，張慧玉，林佳靜，2009，〈末期病人面臨預立醫囑、生前預囑之現況及生命自決之倫理議題〉，《護理雜誌》56：1，頁17-22。 王英煒，2010，〈新安寧運動下的倫理思維〉，《澄清醫護管理雜誌》，6：1，頁4-11。 蔡甫昌，2006，〈重症加護病患照護之倫理爭議〉，《台灣醫學》，10：1，頁105-114。 蘇文浩，2006，〈癌末病患的醫療倫理〉，《哲學與文化》，33:4，頁5-15。 四、 英文參考書目 Beauchamp, Tom L. & Childress, James F.,2001, Principles of Biomedical Ethics. (fifth edition) Oxford University Press. Beauchamp, Tom L. & Childress, James F.,2009, Principles of Biomedical Ethics. (sixth edition) Oxford University Press. Beauchamp, Tom L. &Walters, Le Roy.,2003, Contemporary Issues in Bioethics. (sixth edition)Wadsworth, a division of Thomson Learning, Inc. Beauchamp, Tom L. &Walters, Le Roy.et al.,2008, Contemporary Issues in Bioethics. (seventh edition),Wadsworth, a division of Thomson Learning, Inc. Dworkin, Ronald.,1994. Life’’s Dominion an Argument about Abortion, Euthanasia, and Individual Freedom. New York : Vintage Books. Dworkin,Ronald ,1997, Taking Rights Seriously, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. Gewirth, Alan,1982, Human Rights Essays on Justification and Applications. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London. Kant,Immanuel,1964, Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, translated and analysed by H.J. Paton,Harper&Raw,Publishers ,New York Kant, Immanuel, 1997, Lectures on Ethics, edited by Peter Heath& J. B. Schneewind, translated by Peter Heath. Cambridge University Press. La Follette, Hugh, 2000, Ethics in Practice—An Anthology. Blackwell Publishers Inc. Pojman, Louis P., 2000, Life and Death—A Reader in Moral Problems. Wadsworth Publishing Company. Rawls ,John ,1999, A Theory of Justice, revised edition, Harvard University Press. Singer, Peter,1993, Practical Ethics. second edition. Cambridge University Press. Uhlmann ,M.M. ,1998, Last Right? –assisted suicide and euthanasia debated. Ethics and Public Policy Center, Washington, D.C. Waldron, Jeremy, 1989, Theories of Rights, New York: Oxford University Press. 五、 英文期刊、論文 Abu-Saad H., Ter Meulen R.H.J.,2007, “Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide in the Dutch homecare sector: the role of the district nurse. ” Journal of Advanced Nursing 58(1), 44–52. http://www.tehrantimes.com/Index_view.asp?code=191410 Asch, D.A.,1996,.“The role of critical care nurses in Euthanasia and assisted suicide. ”New England Journal of Medicine. 334:21, 1347-1379. Baker, Idris, Lennon,Colin, 2008, “Would assisted dying damage palliative care? ”Pulse, 68:23, 18-19. Battin, M. P.,1995, “Ethical issues in Physician-assisted suicide. ” in Uhlmann M.M,. 1998, Last Right? –assisted suicide and euthanasia debated. Ethics and public policy center, Washington, D. C., p. 111-146 Battin, M. P.,Van der Heide A Ganzini, L., van der Wal, G., & Onwuteaka-Philipsen, B.D.,2007, “Legal physician- assisted dying in Oregon and the Netherlands: evidence concerning the impact on patients in "vulnerable" groups. ” Journal of Medical Ethics, 3(10):591-597. Beauchamp, Tom L.,2000, “Justifying Physician-Assisted Deaths. ” in La Follette, Hugh., Ethics in Practice—an Anthology. Blackwell Publishers Inc. Bernheim Jan L., Mullie A ,2010,“Euthanasia and palliative care in Belgium: Legitimate concerns and unsubstantiated grievances. ” Journal of Palliative Medicine,13(7):798-799. Bilsen J., Vander Stichele R., Mortier F. & Deliens L. ,2004, Involvement of nurses in physician-assisted dying. Journal of Advanced Nursing 47(6), 583–591. Bittel N, Neuenschwander H, Stiefel F.“"Euthanasia": a survey by the Swiss Association for Palliative Care. ”Supportive Care Cancer ,2002; 10: 265-271. Blevins D, Preston T S, Werth J L,2005,“Characteristics of persons approving of physician-assisted death. ”Death Studies, 29: 601–623. Bosshard G ,Ulrich E , Ziegler S. J , Bär W,2008, “Assessment of Requests for Assisted Suicide by a Swiss right-to die society. ”Death Studies, 32: 646–657. Breitbart W, Heller K S,2003, “Reframing Hope: Meaning-Centered Care for Patients Near the End of Life. ” Palliative Medicine, 6(6): 979-988. Breitbart, William ,2000,“Depression, hopelessness, and desire for hastened death in terminally ill patients with cancer. ”JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association, 284(22):2907-11 Buiting H, et al ,2009, “Reporting of euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide in Netherlands: descriptive study. ”BMC Medical Ethics, 10:18. http://www.biomecentral.com/1472-6939/10/18 Callahan, Daniel,1996,“The legalization of physician-assisted suicide：Creating a Potemkin village. ”in Michael.M. Uhlmann,1998, Last Right? Ethics and public policy center, Washington,D.C. p577-598. Chambaere G, Bilsen J, Cohen J,2010,“Physician-assisted deaths under the euthanasia law in Belgium: a population-based survey. ” CMAJ , 182(9): 895-901. Cohen-Almagor, Raphael ,2009,.“Euthanasia policy and practice in Belgium: Critical observations and suggestions for improvement. ” Issues in law & medicine, 24( 3):187-21. Dierckx de Casterlé, B., Denier, Y., De Bal, N. and Gastmans, C. ,2010, “Nursing care for patients requesting euthanasia in general hospitals in Flanders, Belgium. ” Journal of Advanced Nursing, 66:2410–2420. Dickinson G, Clark D, Winslow M, Marples R,2005,“US physicians’ attitudes concerning euthanasia and physician-assisted death: A systematic literature review. ” Mortality,10(1):43-52. Emanuel EJ, Fairclough DL, Daniels ER,1996,“Euthanasia and Assisted suicide: attitudes and experience among oncology patients, oncologists and the public”. Lancet.347:1805-10. Emanuel EJ, Fairclough DL, Emanuel LL,2000, “Attitudes and desires related to euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide among terminally ill patients and their caregivers. ” JAMA. 284(19): 2460-2468. Emanuel, E. J. ,2002, “Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide: A review of the empirical data from the United States. ” Arch Intern Med, 162: 142-152. Ganzini, Linda, Goy Elizabeth R., Dobscha Steven K., 2007, “Why Oregon patients request assisted death: Family members’ views. ” Society of General Internal Medicine, 23(2):154-7. Ganzini L, Harvath T A, Jackson A, Goy E, Miller L L& Delorit M A,2002, “Experiences of Oregon nurses and social workers with hospice patients who requested assistance with suicide” New England Journal of Medicine, 347:582-88. Gielen J, Stef van den Branden , Bert Broeckaert,2009, “Religion and nurses’ attitude to euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide. ” Nursing Ethics, 16 (3):303-318. Gielen J, van den Branden S, van Iersel T, Broeckaert B,2009, “Flemish palliative care nurses’ attitudes toward euthanasia: a quantitative study. ” Int J Palliat Nurs 15:488–497. Gill ,Michael B., 2009, “Is the Legalization of Physician-Assisted Suicide Compatible with Good End-of-Life Care. ” Journal of Applied Philosophy, 26(1):27-45. Graeff, Alexander De,2007, “Palliative Sedation Therapy in the Last Weeks of Life: A Literature Review and Recommendations for Standards. ” Journal of Palliative Medicine.10(1):67-85. Heide, Agnes van der,. Onwuteaka-Philipsen, Bregje D.., Rurup Mette L., Buiting ,Hilde M.., 2007 ,“End-of-Life Practices in the Netherlands under the Euthanasia Act. ”N Engl J Med; 356:1957-1965 Hendin ,Herbert,1995, “Assisted Suicide and euthanasia: The Dutch experience. ” in Michael.M. Uhlmann,1998, Last Right? –assisted suicide and euthanasia debated. Ethics and public policy center, Washington,D.C. p.367-386. Hendin ,Herbert, Foley, Kathleen,2008, “Physician-Assisted Suicide In Oregon: A Medical Perspective. ”Michigan Law Review. Vol. 106:1613-1639. Hicks, Madelyn Hsiao-Rei,2006, “Physician assisted suicide: a review of the literature concerning practical and clinical implications for UK doctors. ”BMC Family Practice, 7(39):17[ http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2296/7/39] Holt ,Janet.,2008, “Nurses’’ attitudes to euthanasia: the influence of empirical studies and methodological concerns on nursing practice. ” Nursing Philosophy , 9(4): 257-272. Hurst S. A., Mauron A,2003,“Assisted suicide and euthanasia in Switzerland: allowing a role for non-physicians. ”BMJ,326:271-273. Inghelbrecht E, Bilsen J, Mortier F, et al. ,2010, “The role of nurses in physician- assisted deaths in Belgium. ”Canadian Medical Association J. 182:9, 905-910 Kass ,Leon R. ,1992,“Why docters must not kill. ”In Michael.M. Uhlmann ,1998, Last Right? Ethics and public policy center, Washington,D.C.p.297-306. Kass ,Leon R.,1993,“Is there a right to die. ” In Beauchamp, Tom L. &Walters, Le Roy.,2003, Contemporary Issues in Bioethics（sixth edition）Wadsworth, a division of Thomson Learning, Inc.p.191-200. Kamisar, Yale ,2008,“Foreword: can Glucksberg survive Lawrence?-Another look at the end of life and personal autonomy. ” Michigan Law Review, Vol. 106: 1453-1478. King, Phyllis, Jordan-Wehch, Marti. ,2003,“Nurse-Assisted Suicide: Answer in End-of life Care. ”Issue in Mental Health Nursing, 24:45-57. Lachman, Vicki D.,2010,“Physician-assisted suicide: Compassionate liberation or murder? ”Medsurg Nursing, 19:2,121-125. Larson,E.J.(2004)“Euthanasia in America—past,present,and future:A review of a merciful end and forced exit. ” Michigan Law Review,vol.102:1245-1262. Lindsay R. A. ,2009,“Oregon’s experience: Evaluating the record. ” The American Journal of Bioethics, 9(3),19-27. Mathes M. M.,2004, “Assisted Suicide and Nursing Ethics. ” Medsurg Nursing, 13(4):261-264. Miller, L.L, Harvath, T.A ,2004, “Attitudes and experiences of Oregon hospice nurses and social workers regarding assisted suicide. ” Palliative Medicine 18:685-691. O’reilly,K. B.,2006.11.6, “Oregon nixes use of term‘physician- assisted suicide’ ” American Medical News. Pence, Gregory,2000,“Why physicians should aid the dying? In La Follette, Hugh., Ethics in Practice—an Anthology. ” Blackwell Publishers Inc.p. 22-32. Quaghebeur ,Toon, de Casterlé, Bernadette Dierckx and Gastmans, Chris,2009, “Nursing and Euthanasia:a review of argument-based ethics literature” Nursing Ethics ,16 (4):465-486. Quill T. E. ,1993, “Death and dignity: A. The case of Diane”. in M.M. Uhlmann ,1998, Last Right? –assisted suicide and euthanasia debated. Ethics and public policy center, Washington, D.C. p. 319-325 Quill, T. E. ,1993,“Death and dignity: B. Potential clinical criteria for physician- assisted suicide. ” in Michael.M. Uhlmann,1998, Last Right? –assisted suicide and euthanasia debated. Ethics and public policy center, Washington, D.C.p.326-335 .Quill ,T.E., 2007 ,“Legal regulation of physician-assisted death-The lastest report cards ” N Engl J Med.356:1911-1913. Rurik Löfmarket al,2008, “Physicians’’ experiences with end-of-life decision- making: Survey in European countries and Australia. ” BMC Medicine , 6:4,1-8 http://www.biomedcentral.com/1741-7015/6/4 Ryynanen OP, Myllykangas M, Viren M, Heino H,2002,“Attitudes towards euthanasia among physicians, nurses and the general public in Finland. ” Public Health.116(6):322-331. Seale ,C,2006, “National survey of end-of life decisions made by UK medical practitioners. ” Palliative medicine, 20:3-10 Seale, C,2009,“End-of-life decisions in the UK involving medical practitioners ”Palliative Medicine 2009; 23: 198–204. Seale, C,2009, “Legalization of euthanasia or physician assisted suicide: Survey of doctor’s attitude. ”Palliative Medicine,23:205-12. Salladay, S.A. ,2004, “Clinician-assisted suicide: Merciful release or unlawful death? ”Journal of Christian Nursing, 21(4), 14-17. Suarez-Almazor ME, Newman C, Hanson J, Bruera E.,2002, “Attitudes of terminally ill cancer patients about euthanasia and assisted suicide: predominance of psychosocial determinants and beliefs over symptom distress and subsequent survival. ” Jounal Clinical Oncology. 15; 20(8):2134-41. Toon Quaghebeur, Bernadette Dierckx de Casterlé and Chris Gastmans,2009, “Nursing and euthanasia: A review of argument-based ethics literature. ” Nursing Ethics, 16(4), 466-486. Van Brruchem-van de Scheur ,GG , van der Arend A.J.G.,2008,“Euthanasia and assisted suicide in Dutch hospitals: the role of nurses. ”Journal of Clinical Nursing,17:1618-1626. Van Bruchem-van de Scheur G.G., van der Arend A.J.G., Spreeuwenberg C., Huijer Westefeld,John S,Doobay,A, Hill j, 2009, “The Oregon Death with Dignity Act: The right to live or the right to die? ”Journal of Loss and Trauma, 14:161-169. Willian Lee, Annabel Price, Lauren Rayner, Matthew Hotopf,2009 ,“ Survey of Doctor’s Opinions of the Legalization of Physician Assisted Suicide. ” BMC Medical Ethics,10(2) , 1-12. Young HoYun,Kyung Hee Han, Sohee Park,ect al,2011,“Attitude of cancer patients,family caregivers,oncologists and members of the general public toward critical interventions at end of life of terminal ill patients. ” CMAJ ,vol.183 (10): E673-679.
指導教授	李瑞全(Shui-Chuen Lee)	審核日期	2012-6-18
推文	facebook   plurk   twitter   funp   google   live   udn   HD   myshare   reddit   netvibes   friend   youpush   delicious   baidu
網路書籤	Google bookmarks   del.icio.us   hemidemi   myshare